Deploying a Secondary Email Domain: DNS, Security, and Deliverability Checklist

Stop waiting for the next Gmail outage — create a verified secondary email domain now

If your org relies on Gmail for critical communications, a single platform change or outage in 2025–26 can halt onboarding, customer support, and incident response. This guide gives technology teams a practical, step-by-step runbook to register, verify, and operate a secondary domain with correct DNS, deliverability signals, and routing so you can fail over quickly — and without a hit to inbox placement.

Executive summary — what to do first (inverted pyramid)

Most important actions to complete in your first 48 hours:

1. Register a secondary domain (short, brand-aligned subdomain or new TLD) and add it to your DNS provider.
2. Create MX records pointing to an alternate mail provider (hosted MTA or transactional provider) and validate inbound mail flows.
3. Publish SPF, DKIM, and DMARC for the new domain — DMARC with p=none initially to gather reports.
4. Verify the domain with your outbound provider(s) and configure DKIM selectors with at least 2048-bit keys.
5. Configure routing & failover so users and systems automatically switch to the secondary for outbound and inbound if Gmail is degraded.
6. Start monitoring — DMARC aggregate reports, MX checks, and deliverability metrics daily.

Why a secondary domain matters in 2026

Late 2025 and early 2026 introduced major product and policy shifts from Gmail: AI-driven inbox experiences, new privacy defaults, and UI flows that change how addresses and identities are presented. For many orgs this increased the risk surface for deliverability and continuity. A verified secondary domain is now a standard resilience pattern — it ensures continuity during provider policy changes, large-scale inbox classification shifts, or regional outages.

Real-world scenarios where a backup domain saved operations

• Support teams routing incident emails to a non-Gmail domain during a 6-hour Gmail service disruption.
• Marketing turning off a Gmail-based envelope for transactional email when AI-driven inbox pre-aggregation caused deliverability drops.
• Security teams switching alerts to a secondary domain during an account-wide compromise or forced re-auth flows.

Tip: Treat the secondary domain as a production asset — own its reputation, not just the DNS record.

Checklist — required DNS & deliverability configuration

• MX records for inbound mail
• SPF TXT with appropriate includes and <=10 DNS lookups
• DKIM selectors with 2048-bit keys
• DMARC TXT with rua (aggregate) and ruf (optional forensic) addresses; start with p=none
• MTA-STS policy and TLS reporting
• ARC if you rely on heavy forwarding workflows
• Monitoring for MX/DNS changes, DMARC reports, and daily inbox placement tests

Step-by-step: Create and verify a backup email domain

1) Choose and register the domain

Pick a short, memorable domain — use a subdomain (e.g., team-alt.example) or a new TLD like example-alt.com. Avoid hyphens and characters that look like phishing. Register with your corporate registrar and ensure you control the WHOIS contact and DNS delegation.

2) Provision DNS and plan the namespace

At minimum, create the zone and enable programmatic access (API/IaC). Recommended records to plan:

• A/AAAA records for any mail web services
• MX records for inbound mail
• TXT records for SPF, DMARC, and verification
• CNAME records for provider verification (SendGrid, Mailgun, SES)
• _mta-sts and a web endpoint for MTA-STS

3) Configure MX records for inbound mail

Decide whether the secondary domain will be active (always receiving) or passive (switch only when needed).

• Active: point MX to a hosted provider or your MX cluster so mail is accepted immediately.
• Passive: keep MX records minimal and update quickly on failover — this requires automation.

Example MX records for provider mail-alt.example (hosted service):

example-alt.com.   3600  IN MX 10 mx1.mail-alt.example.
example-alt.com.   3600  IN MX 20 mx2.mail-alt.example.

Note: lower preference value = higher priority. Keep an SLA on the backup MX provider similar to your primary.

4) Publish SPF correctly

SPF prevents spoofing of MAIL FROM addresses. For a secondary domain, include only authorized outbound hosts and avoid exceeding the 10 DNS lookup limit.

Example SPF:

example-alt.com.  3600  IN TXT "v=spf1 include:spf.mailprovider.com include:spf.sendgrid.net -all"

Operational tips:

• Use -all in production; start ~all while testing.
• Flatten SPF if you need to remove nested includes but be conscious of IP changes.

5) Configure DKIM — 2048-bit keys

DKIM cryptographically signs headers so receivers can verify mail authenticity. Use at least 2048-bit keys in 2026.

Example DKIM (selector alt1):

alt1._domainkey.example-alt.com. 3600 IN TXT "v=DKIM1; k=rsa; p=MIIBIjANBgkq..."

Implementation notes:

• Generate keys on your MTA or let the provider manage keys for you (recommended for SaaS providers).
• Publish both primary and a rollover selector before changeover to enable key rotation with zero downtime.

6) Publish DMARC and start collecting reports

DMARC provides a policy and reporting. Start with p=none and an aggregate reporting address you control. Analyze reports for 7–14 days before stepping up to p=quarantine or p=reject.

_dmarc.example-alt.com. 3600 IN TXT "v=DMARC1; p=none; rua=mailto:dmarc-agg@reports.example.com; ruf=mailto:dmarc-fails@reports.example.com; pct=100; fo=1"

Operational tips:

• Use a DMARC analysis tool (DMARCian, Valimail, MxToolbox) to parse aggregate XML.
• Do not move to p=reject until all legitimate senders are authorized via SPF/DKIM.

7) MTA-STS and TLS-RPT (encrypt and monitor SMTP transport)

To improve deliverability and mitigate active transport-layer tampering, publish an MTA-STS policy and enable TLS reporting. MTA-STS requires a TXT DNS entry and a policy file hosted over HTTPS.

Example DNS TXT:

_mta-sts.example-alt.com. 3600 IN TXT "v=STSv1; id=20260115"

Then publish the HTTPS policy at https://mta-sts.example-alt.com/.well-known/mta-sts.txt with contents like:

version: STSv1
mode: enforce
max_age: 604800
mx: mx1.mail-alt.example
mx: mx2.mail-alt.example

Enable TLS reporting (tlsrpt) with an address that receives reports from receivers. Monitor these reports to detect rejected TLS connections.

8) ARC and forwarded mail

If your workflows rely on forwarding (helpdesk, CRM routing), configure ARC at your outbound MTA to preserve authentication claims through forwarding chains. This reduces false positives in recipient spam filtering.

9) Verify the domain with outbound providers

Most transactional or marketing providers require DNS records for domain verification. Typical steps:

1. Create provider's TXT or CNAME verification record.
2. Publish provider-specific DKIM selector if using provider signing.
3. Confirm SPF includes or set a dedicated sending subdomain (recommended).

Example for SendGrid-style CNAME verification:

em123.example-alt.com. 3600 IN CNAME sendgrid.net.

10) Routing strategies — inbound and outbound continuity

Now map out how mail will flow under normal and failover conditions.

Inbound options

• Always-active MX: Both primary and secondary domains receive mail; update MX TTL and receivers to prioritize primary.
• Passive automatic failover: Keep low TTL on MX and programmatically swap records when an outage is detected.
• Forwarding: Secondary domain forwards to primary inboxes; ensure SPF/DKIM/ARC are preserved.

Outbound options

• SMTP relay failover: Configure clients and MTAs to try primary SMTP then secondary.
• Subdomain split: Use send.example.com for primary and send-alt.example for the backup; update DNS and client configs to switch quickly.
• Provider dual-sending: Some SaaS providers support dual delivery; test sending from both domains for warmup.

11) Client & automation configuration

Update your organization's runbooks and endpoint configs:

• Mail clients: provide profiles for both domains and document when to switch.
• Ticketing & automation: ensure outbound notifications can be sent from the secondary domain (API keys configured).
• CI/CD and monitoring: integrate DNS and MX checks into your SRE dashboards.

Deliverability best practices for the secondary domain

Creating the domain is only the start — maintain its reputation.

1. Warm up sending IPs or domains: ramp volume across days with consistent content and engagement-based targeting.
2. Use separate subdomains for high-volume marketing so transactional and security emails maintain reputation.
3. Keep DMARC in monitor mode until you confirm all legitimate mail paths pass SPF or DKIM.
4. Monitor blacklists and feedback loops and configure ISP FBLs for the backup provider where available.
5. Avoid domain mix-ups: never mix primary & secondary sending without explicit address alignment and identity headers.

Example warmup schedule (simple)

• Day 1-3: 100 messages/day to engaged recipients
• Day 4-7: 500 messages/day, monitor bounces and complaints
• Week 2+: scale by 2x daily with ongoing monitoring

Verification, testing, and monitoring — the continuous loop

Build a testing cadence and automated alerts:

• Weekly inbox placement tests (Gmail, Outlook, Yahoo).
• Daily DMARC aggregate parsing and summary alerts for new sources.
• MX, TLS, and DNS-monitoring that alerts on TTL and record drift.
• Automated failover tests (quarterly): swap MX for an hour and validate inbound and outbound flows.

Production test checklist

1. Send signed DKIM email to seed list and verify signature intact on delivery.
2. Trigger DMARC reports by sending to reporting addresses and verify parsing.
3. Run a deliverability test to major ISPs and inspect headers for SPF/DKIM/DMARC results.
4. Test SMTP TLS connection to major recipients and check MTA-STS enforcement.

Advanced considerations (2026 trends)

Use these if you need stronger guarantees:

• BIMI + VMC: Increasing ISP support in 2025–26 makes BIMI (with a verified mark certificate) useful for brand trust in major inboxes.
• Dedicated IPs vs shared pools: Dedicated IPs give control but require careful warmup and maintenance.
• ARC for complex forwarding: With more AI summarization and forwarding by inboxes in 2026, ARC helps preserve authentication across hops.
• Certificate management: Keep OTA certificate automation for your MTA and web endpoints (Let's Encrypt or enterprise CA).

Operational runbook (one-page)

Keep a concise runbook for when Gmail degrades:

1. Confirm Gmail outage via Google Workspace status and internal monitoring.
2. Switch outbound SMTP host to smtp-alt.example-alt.com or flip provider in your MTA config.
3. If inbound passive: update MX records (low TTL makes this faster) to point to the secondary MX. If active: validate delivery and inform teams.
4. Notify staff and update public-facing pages with the temporary contact domain/address.
5. Monitor DMARC and bounce rates — keep a tight feedback channel with the backup provider.

Example MTA config snippet: Postfix transport map for failover

# /etc/postfix/transport
primary.example.com    smtp:[smtp.primary.example]:587
example-alt.com        smtp:[smtp.alt.example]:587

# postmap /etc/postfix/transport

Common pitfalls and how to avoid them

• Publishing DMARC too strict too soon — analyze reports first.
• Not rotating DKIM keys before changeover — publish the new key early.
• Exceeding SPF DNS lookups — use include sparingly or a dedicated sending subdomain.
• Failing to warm up sending IPs — causes sudden spam-scores and blocks.
• Assuming MX changes propagate instantly — use low TTL and automation for speed, but verify propagation.

2026 predictions — why resilient email architecture becomes standard

Through late 2025 and into 2026, inbox AI (e.g., Gemini-powered Gmail features), more aggressive privacy/sorting defaults, and vendor policy shifts are increasing the rate of unexpected deliverability changes. Organizations that adopt a secondary domain pattern will see fewer operational interruptions and faster recovery from provider policy changes. Expect more ISPs to require MTA-STS/TLS reporting and wider BIMI adoption among major mailbox providers.

Actionable takeaways — what to implement this week

1. Register and create DNS for a short secondary domain this afternoon.
2. Publish MX, SPF (start with ~all), DKIM selector, and DMARC (p=none) within 24 hours.
3. Verify the domain with your outbound provider and send test messages to seed inboxes.
4. Set up MTA-STS and TLS reporting and subscribe to a DMARC parser tool.
5. Add failover steps to your incident runbook and schedule a quarterly failover drill.

Resources and tools

• DMARC parsing services: DMARCian, Valimail, MxToolbox
• Deliverability testing: GlockApps, Litmus, Mail-Tester
• DNS monitoring: DNSMadeEasy, Route 53 health checks, automated Terraform for DNS

Final checklist (copy-paste for your team)

• [ ] Domain registered and WHOIS locked
• [ ] Zone created and API access enabled
• [ ] MX records published and tested
• [ ] SPF TXT published and validated
• [ ] DKIM selectors published and test signatures pass
• [ ] DMARC TXT published (p=none) and reports flowing
• [ ] MTA-STS policy hosted and TLS-RPT enabled
• [ ] Domain verified with outbound provider
• [ ] Failover runbook documented and scheduled tests created
• [ ] Monitoring/alerts wired into SRE dashboards

Call to action

Don’t wait until a Gmail disruption forces an emergency DNS change. Register a verified secondary domain today, apply the checklist above, and run one failover drill this month. Need a ready-to-run Terraform module or a Postfix/Exim template for automated failover? Contact our team or download the Helps.Website runbook templates to deploy a hardened secondary email domain in under a day.

Related Reading

• After the Fall: What Saks Global’s Chapter 11 Means for Luxury Watch and Jewelry Investors
• Pitching TV-Style Formats to Digital Platforms: What Creators Can Learn from Broadcaster-Streamer Deals
• Moderator Burnout vs. Airport Safety Staff: Building Mental Health Support for People Who Watch the Worst Content
• Ambient Lighting for Cars: Use RGBIC Lamps Without Draining Your Battery
• Segregating Email Identities for Torrenting: Why Google's Changes Mean You Need a New Address